It looks great, but try to make it even more blizzlike.For example, the water color is not that blizzlike.The Inner Shadow of the whole map must be darker.Anyway, keep up the good work, I like it.
Wow. This is amazing cartography. I really envy that. Did you make the map icons yourself?Also the region names are really cool too. Everything about it is awesome xD
Lorely speaking this island isn't very big, has a lot of mountains with rocky coasts, and the bloodsail buccaners rule it mainly. Though the map you drew is really nice I will also probably do this island, though I don't think it will be as big as your version. I see it as a land with a lot of caverns, menacing sharp rocks with murlocs on the border, luxurious jungle at the top with even more mountains, wooden pirate city in the cliff of the coast with a curved citadel, and a plateau at the center with basiliks. Me not being an expert about drawing maps, I will instead give you advices about the way you could make your island : I would probably try to make some Gilneas texturing style, but with warm colors. Like orange colors for the mountains, but darker than Tanaris. It would be nice to have menacing mountains, inspiring terror !
I see, it does sound nice, though you'll need a lot of quests to make so much levels feat into those restricted areas.
The theory about Hiji is nice, though if the name changed, then you have to imagine that Troll are not so much in shape right now because of pirates.