|
Forum > Showoff - what you are working on
[SHOWOFF] Skarn - Some Progress So Far
<< < (3/7) > >>
Elinora:
I'm actually a huge fan of this project. Please, post more ^^
Allifeur:
I'm still not a big fan of your project yet because the creation of your maps is still too dependant of Blizzard's works.
Despite of a great work on atmosphere, there are only a few of true texture work, it's almost only object spawning and skybox work. The canyon is awesome, but it was made from Blizzard's emerald dream, I can't applaud it fully. The Thor'zain pass mainly exist because of the M2 ground, when it came to personal ground texturing, my eyes started to burn (cf here : http://i.imgur.com/XLUnOhN.jpg )
About Bolvar's texture on several races, please, please, change those women textures, those body-builded ladies are true pain for my sense of beauty. Though, if you will was to make a strong lady without sexism, then go on, you have an excuse that I shall accept despite the terrible aspect of it.
Gehenna's is mainly dependant of Firelands. Plus, some choices of objects are still weird.
==> http://i.imgur.com/IUFcWRx.jpg Come on, wood ? :O
About the Drow Prison, I only see Ahn'kahet dephts used as a background zone, in which you roughly added zangdar M2s, rocks, qiraji ruins and thorns. This aera itself is a reuse of Shadowmoon valley textures by Blizzard, only turning green lava to red. And this is not honest to post landscapes as if it was your creation when it's not, like there : http://i.imgur.com/bUY55OR.jpg
I actually respect more the last work, about the Orc Starting Zone, even if it's the ugliest. At least, I can see that you're starting to see what it is truly to have to texture an aera.
Ah, and my apology for being so rude. I'm still waiting to see that project progress more. It wouldn't be fun if there weren't someone telling he doesn't like the result :roll:
Elinora:
--- Quote from: "Allifeur" ---I'm still not a big fan of your project yet because the creation of your maps is still too dependant of Blizzard's works.
Despite of a great work on atmosphere, there are only a few of true texture work, it's almost only object spawning and skybox work. The canyon is awesome, but it was made from Blizzard's emerald dream, I can't applaud it fully. The Thor'zain pass mainly exist because of the M2 ground, when it came to personal ground texturing, my eyes started to burn (cf here : http://i.imgur.com/XLUnOhN.jpg )
About Bolvar's texture on several races, please, please, change those women textures, those body-builded ladies are true pain for my sense of beauty. Though, if you will was to make a strong lady without sexism, then go on, you have an excuse that I shall accept despite the terrible aspect of it.
Gehenna's is mainly dependant of Firelands. Plus, some choices of objects are still weird.
==> http://i.imgur.com/IUFcWRx.jpg Come on, wood ? :O
About the Drow Prison, I only see Ahn'kahet dephts used as a background zone, in which you roughly added zangdar M2s, rocks, qiraji ruins and thorns. This aera itself is a reuse of Shadowmoon valley textures by Blizzard, only turning green lava to red. And this is not honest to post landscapes as if it was your creation when it's not, like there : http://i.imgur.com/bUY55OR.jpg
I actually respect more the last work, about the Orc Starting Zone, even if it's the ugliest. At least, I can see that you're starting to see what it is truly to have to texture an aera.
Ah, and my apology for being so rude. I'm still waiting to see that project progress more. It wouldn't be fun if there weren't someone telling he doesn't like the result :roll:
--- End quote ---
I think I can help him with the hand-drawn texturework.
stoneharry:
--- Quote from: "Allifeur" ---I'm still not a big fan of your project yet because the creation of your maps is still too dependant of Blizzard's works.
--- End quote ---
What does this have to do with anything? It's completely fine to use existing assets. We don't have to be elitist and only use our own work.
Allifeur:
--- Quote from: "stoneharry" ---
--- Quote from: "Allifeur" ---I'm still not a big fan of your project yet because the creation of your maps is still too dependant of Blizzard's works.
--- End quote ---
What does this have to do with anything? It's completely fine to use existing assets. We don't have to be elitist and only use our own work.
--- End quote ---
I don't say this is bad, I just say this is not enough for me to like it.
I just dislike the fact of reusing too much Blizzard's base : people will think the whole thing was made by them. It's like taking a paint, changing the colors, adding a mustach and claim it's your. That's how I see it.
Though the fact of reworking on Blizzard's map isn't bad itself, I do it sometimes, but this is not impressive if you only do that. I never make a show off for that kind of works.
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
|